An American Requiem: God, My Father, and the War that Came Between Us – James Carroll

RequiemOn August 1, 1961, United States Secretary of Defense Robert S. McNamara (1916-2009) established the Defense Intelligence Agency (“DIA”) which became operational on October 1, 1961. The new agency was assigned the task of acting as a central hub for the coordination and monitoring of the United States intelligence apparatus. In the wake of the Bay of Pigs Invasion in April 1961 and its disastrous aftermath, President John F. Kennedy (1917-1963) sought to regain control over America’s intelligence operations. McNamara tapped Lt. Gen. Joseph Carroll (1910-1991), a former special agent for the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”), to lead the DIA in its assigned mission to place power of the intelligence community in the hands of the president. Carroll and and his wife Mary had five sons, one of whom is the author of this book, James Carroll.  This is his story of how he found his way in the Church, his differences of opinion with his father on society’s issues, and how events during the 1960s altered the relationship between them.

Carroll, his siblings, and parents are the typical American family of the 1960s on appearance. For James, his middle-class upbringing progresses without fanfare. However, for his father Joseph, things were far more serious as the Cold War and Vietnam heated up. Domestically, the Civil Rights Movement was pressing full steam ahead and became a hotbed issue across America. Ideologically, father and son found themselves on opposite ends of the spectrum as the younger Carroll found a calling in religion. And as he moves priesthood to the delight of Francis Cardinal Spellman (1889-1967), he finds himself developing a negative view of the war, dedicated support for civil rights, and irritation at the claim of a “missile gap” with the Soviet Union.  The seeds had been planted and in 1969, Carroll was ordained into the priesthood to the delight of his parents who are proud of their priest son.

The Vietnam War remains controversial and has been called America’s “least popular” conflict. My uncle who served in Vietnam, recalled that when flying home after his tour, senior officers told troops to change into civilian clothes before leaving the aircraft and going home due to the hostile protestors waiting for returning soldiers. He went on to describe the names they were called, and soldiers being spat on by anti-war demonstrators. As the war rages, James becomes more disillusioned with the war, but he also knows that the relationship with his dad will become strained should his anti-war position become officially known, due to the father’s high rank in military circles. It becomes a cat and mouse game as the author explains the efforts, he employed to prevent his father from seeing his anti-war efforts at a time when Washington was committed to victory.  His analysis of the conflict and decisions by senior officials provokes thought, and highlights the miscalculations made by Washington in supporting the regime of South Vietnamese President Ngo Dinh Diem (1901-1963), whose assassination casted a dark omen over the conflict and preceded Kennedy’s assassination in Dallas, Texas in November 1963. Eventually, the war did end, but the two Carrolls still had a rough road ahead.

In 1974, Carroll left the priesthood and shocked his parents. His decisions and feelings about it are explained, as well as the fallout at home as his staunchly Catholic parents learn that their son is leaving the clergy. It is a tough section in the book, and I can only imagine the pressure Carroll was under as he came to realize that he wanted a different path in life, which included a wife and kids who also are discussed in the story. In fact, there is one section regarding a road trip where his wife confronts him regarding the senior Carroll’s actions behind the wheel.  But what we also see is the first stage of decline for Joseph as he falls victim to a condition many of us have witnessed in our families. The author takes us step by step as the family does its best to support the aging patriarch, all the way to the end until he passes away surrounded by family.

When I finished the book, I was thoroughly satisfied with the purchase. Carroll writes beautifully, and the story is as American as you can get. The difference in opinions from one generation to the next, compounded by faith and issues of morality are what make the story relatable. Regardless of where we come from, every family has its struggles, and for the Carrolls, those challenges had long lasting effects. But the author never stopped loving his father and that should not be lost to the reader. Surely, there are tough moments in the book, and when the two do have difficult discussions, the elder Carroll’s softer side does come out. But he was also a man of code, and his profession required a level of discipline at a time when the world was on the brink of nuclear war and social upheaval had gripped the planet. And despite their challenges, both father and son are what make the story as compelling as it is.  Highly recommended.

First, that no human being has the right to sit in absolute judgment of another. Second, the essential note of our relationship to God, and to each other, must be forgiveness.” – James Carroll

ASIN :‎ B0062EAWVU
Publisher :‎ Mariner Books; Reprint edition (April 1, 1997)

Caesar: Life of a Colossus – Adrian Goldsworthy

CaesarRecently, I was searching for new material to read but was not sure which subject matter I should choose. The choice was made for me when I saw this book on the Roman General and Statesman Gaius Julius Caesar (100 B.C. -44 B.C.). Of course, the name is known worldwide, but how well do we know the real story behind the man whose murder has become a case study for betrayal? Personally, I knew that there was much to learn about his life, and I decided to take the plunge and give this a read. Having finished the book, I can say that there is far more to extraordinary story than the last moments on March 15, 44 B.C., when his life reached its conclusion in Rome. Adrian Goldsworthy looks at Caesar’s life in this book which gripping from beginning to end.

Most of us have seen the films ‘Gladiator‘ (2000) and the controversial ‘Caligula‘ (1979). Both films provide their own shock value through visual recreations of the life in the ancient world with the latter earning its contested reputation due to the graphic portrayals of sex on screen. Although fiction, the films do contain some truths. There are other films regarding the same, and they provide their own interpretation of an era that seems barbaric today. Life in the ancient world was survival of the fittest and those unable to meet its brutal expectations did not fare well. And in this mix of greed, violence, sexual promiscuity and deception, Caesar navigated his way to an unthinkable position of power that proved to be his downfall. But to understand his death, we first must learn his life’s journey which begins in 100 B.C.

The story begins like a standard biography, providing us with a glimpse into young Caesar’s life and maturity into a young man. However, the story changes gears when Caesar’s father dies unexpectedly when he is in his teens. And when war erupts in 74 B.C., the young man answers the call to serve in battle, setting him on a path that would last the rest of his life. Throughout the book I found the discussions regarding Caesar’s military service fascinating, and they provided me with a better understanding of his historical importance. But I warn readers that post-battle events are testaments to the brutality of the period in which Caesar and his contemporaries lived. Those who found themselves on the losing end of a conflict could expect slavery, pillage, and things far worse. Caesar is in the middle of these events, and his actions, both positive and negative, are explored for the reader to judge. Further, the author writes in a steady narrative that maintains the right pace and suspense to keep readers intrigued.

In addition to his military campaigns, Caesar was a noted statesman, and the author provides a good analysis of how government in Rome functioned, and the ways in which the seasoned warrior used his fame and success for ascension in society. However, we also learn of Caesar’s fondness for women, aside from his first and second wives. The author pulls no punches about the adultery that transpired, and Caesar was not the only figure to engage in it, but his reputation did suffer tarnish because of it. And more than one woman he chose, had family and social connections that later proved to be ironic twists in his demise, as we learn in the book. Today he would be considered a sex addict and held in the same light as celebrity figures currently in their own legal troubles for nefarious reasons, but in the ancient world, his behavior was common but not condoned.

While Caesar was winning military campaigns, his detractors were keeping a watchful eye over his success. They had not forgotten about the corruption scandals Caesar found himself amid. The incident is discussed by the author and reveals a complex figure. I was surprised at the amount of time Caesar spent outside of Rome in military service. In comparison to a tour of duty today, campaigns in the ancient world were extensive and as shown through Caesar’s story, one could spend years away from home. But he was determined to return to Rome and become a consul. However, plotters were waiting and determined to never let him assume the title. And thus, we arrive at the Civil War of 49 B.C., which left behind an extensive number of dead, including opponents Pompey (106 B.C. – 48 B.C.) and Marcus Porcius Cato (95 B.C. – 46 B.C.). Both had made their opposition to Caesar clear, believing him to be a dictator in the making. They were equally prophetic but the stories behind their positions are crucial to understanding the later plot to take Caesar’s life.

In hindsight, we know Caesar prevailed in the Civil War, but it came with a cost. The opposition to his increasing power, wealth, and rule upon returning to Rome, created a simmering tension. But before we reach the climactic ending we know is coming, there is the entry into the story of two popular figures from the ancient world: Cleopatra VII Thea Philopator (69 B.C.- 30 B.C.) and Marcus Antonios (83 B.C. – 30 B.C.) (“Mark Antony”).  While Cleopatra becomes a love interest of Caesar, Mark Antony plays a significant role in the military campaigns which later bring him success. However, he is not without his own demons addressed in the book. Both would outlive Caesar before meeting their own tragic fates in 30 B.C., but their importance to the story at hand cannot be overlooked. We have heard the story of the senators who assassinated Caesar, but the full extent of the conspiracy is what deserves more context. The author goes deep into the conspiracy, and the links connecting the plotters. Marcus Junius Brutus (85 B.C. – 42 B.C.) is the most popular of Caesar’s killers, but in reality, he was just one of dozens of men who desired to see Caesar’s reign ended. In fact, the conspiracy was far larger than we might have been led to believe. The magnitude of Caesar’s rule came to life in the pages of this book, and it was clear that he attained everything and then lost it, for the Republic has always been more important than one man. This is the life and death of Julius Caesar. Highly recommended.

ASIN ‏ : ‎ B0015R3HJS
Publisher ‏ : ‎ Yale University Press; 1st edition (September 22, 2006)