American Caesar: Douglas McArthur (1880-1964) – William Manchester

On November 11, 2025, the United States will observe Veteran’s Day and  pay its respect to the nation’s military veterans. Eighty years have now passed since the conclusion of World War II. In Europe, Allied Forces battled the Axis powers, fueled by German Chancellor Adolf Hitler‘s (1889-1945) quest for world domination and in the Pacific, Japan was aging its own war as it sought to spread its influence across Asia. Allied resistance to the Pacific was fierce and important as the European campaign, and at the helm was one of the American military’s greatest leaders, General Douglas McArthur (1880-1964). Today there are buildings, airports and streets named for him, but who was this legendary figure in military circles? Author William Manchester (1922-2004) explores his life in this extensive biography that peels back the layers to reveal the man behind the dark sunglasses and corn cob smoking pipe. 

In American military history, McArthur’s name is firmly cemented. Previously, I reviewed H.W. Brand’s ‘The General v. The President: McArthur and Truman at the Brink of Nuclear War‘, which focuses on the fallout between McArthur and United States President Harry S.  Truman (1884-1972). The complicated story of the two powerful figures is also told here by Manchester, and is a crucial part of McArthur’s fall from grace. But before we reach that point, his icredible life takes center stage, and from the beginning I felt myself pulled into the biography. Manchester was a noted historian and a meticulous writer, who had a talent for bringing history to life with vivid clarity and smooth narratives. Readers should be aware that this book is long and contains well over seven hundred pages of text. But contained within it is a wealth of information about an iconic figure. 

Early in the book, it becomes clear that the military is a crucial part of the McArthur family’s life. The role of McArthur’s father Arthur McArthur, Jr. (1845-1912) is firm, and young Douglas proves to be a brilliant student and blessed with high intellect. But no one could have predicted the name he would make for himself later in life. As we follow the young McArthur from one continent to the next, we witness his gains in battlefield experience, exposure to cultures abroad and ascension in military rank. The young bachelor also finds love in the story, and second wife Jean (1898-2000) would prove to be the rock he needed as he moved through life. The addition of son Arthur, IV introduces fatherhood into the story and throughout the book, McArthur embraces his role as protector of his immediately family and a series of islands in the Pacific known as the Philippines. The story behind his god-like status on the islands is explained thoroughly, and includes his actions during World War II (1939-1945) as Japan ramped up its attacks on the small islands. Although Japan was defeated, the threat from Tokyo was real and the McArthurs faced danger more than once before the Allies began to turn the tide. The discussion regarding the war forms a sizeable section of the book for obvious reasons. When Japan does surrender, McArthur also plays a pivotal role in post-war events but there was another looming threat on the horizon also in Asia. 

On June 25, 1950, North Korean troops poured across the 38th Parallel into South Korea igniting the Korean War. The White House sprang into action, and McArthur once again would be called into service. Korea proves to be far more complicated than World War II, and the reasons why are explored by Manchester without taking the focus away from McArthur. However, we also see the rift developing between Truman and the famed general. And when Truman signs NSC-68, 1950, more confusion is added to the mix. For McArthur the situation was simple and he would do what was needed to defeat North Korea. But the White House and America had no desire for another world war. But what happens to the life long combat soldier who has no more wars to fight?Soon a major issue developes and readers will notice that McArthur is somehat of a “Frankenstein” created by the system he served. And when he acts on his own, the stage is set for a showdown with the White House. I understood Truman’s decision regarding McArthur’sremoval but I did question his methods.  Once home in the United States, the story takes another turn as McArthur becomes a national celebrity with public opinion on his side. But it does not last long and the impact to his image is significant. The story is surreal at times and the differences in which he was revered and loathed are striking. By autumn 1953, the world wars were over and McArthur was already back in America, living out his days quietly as his health began to decline. 

As the 1960s approached, McArthur had begun to decline physically, and in the story, we can see the end is near. But even as he was confronting his own mortality, he sill saw himself as the general of service and there is an interesting meeting with President John F. Kennedy (1917-1963) which sent chills down my spine. McArthur would also have a similar discussion with President Lyndon B. Johnson (1908-1973), and we can only wonder what would have happened had his advice been followed. In the spring of 1964, his health turns sharply for the worse and his last days draw near. The book ends with a somber note at Walter Reed Army Medical Center in Bethesda, Maryland as slips away but his death felt strange after a voluminous account of his life which is intertwined with world history. However, we are all mortal and although he is gone, his memory lives on in our rememberance of his name and accomplishments. He truly was the “American Caesar”. 

“People grow old only by deserting their ideals,” MacArthur had written, paraphrasing another writer. “Years may wrinkle the skin, but to give up interest wrinkles the soul.… You are as young as your faith, as old as your doubt; as young as your self-confidence, as old as your fear; as young as your hope, as old as your despair. In the central place of every heart there is a recording chamber; so long as it receives messages of beauty, hope, cheer and courage, so long are you young. When… your heart is covered with the snows of pessimism and the ice of cynicism, then and then only are you grown old—and then, indeed, as the ballad says, you just fade away.”

Publisher ‏ : ‎ Back Bay Books
Publication date ‏ : ‎ May 12, 2008

The Death of a President: November 20 – November 25, 1963 – William Manchester

20220227_145712On November 25, 1963, my mother prepared to celebrate her birthday, but everyone knew there would be little joy that day. While my mother prepared herself for that day, officials in Washington were making the final adjustments to the funeral of President John F. Kennedy (1917-1963). In Texas, the family of Lee Harvey Oswald (1939-1963) also made their adjustments to his funeral after he was shot and killed while in Dallas Police custody by nightclub owner Jack Rubenstein (1911-1967), known more commonly as Jack Ruby. Over the years, my mother has spoken about that day and has always said that it was the saddest birthday she can recall. The sorrow and tear-streaked faces of those around him are images that have been permanently embedded into my father’s memories that are still intact six decades later. Kennedy’s murder will continue to serve as a topic of debate but what is rarely discussed are his reasons for visiting Dallas and the warnings, he received not to travel to a city known for right-wing activity. Author William Manchester (1922-2004) was asked to author a book covering the Dallas trip from start to finish by former first lady Jacqueline (“Jackie”) Kennedy Onassis (1929-1994). And this account is a thorough explanation the five days in which America experienced the death of a president.

Manchester’s book is not an examination of the crime itself but focuses on the Kennedy party as it left Washington and somberly returned home with a fallen leader. Regarding the assassination, Manchester subscribes to the lone gunman theory but keeps Oswald’s story to a minimum. The book keeps its focus on Kennedy and what was left of his administration after the events in Dealey Plaza. To say that there was mass confusion after Kennedy’s murder would be an understatement. Frankly, all hell broke loose, and no one seemed sure of the procedure during a situation that called for instant responses. Shock consumed everyone but as we see in the book, few should have been surprised. Manchester did a thorough job of capturing the political turmoil as Kennedy sought to diffuse an inter-party battle between Senator Ralph Yarborough (1903-1996) (D-TX) and Texas Governor John Connally (1917-1993). A successful intervention by Kennedy would have paved the way for the presentation of a united Democrat front heading into the 1964 election. But those plans died with Kennedy on November 22, and I am sure that following the assassination, Yarborough must have realized how close he came to being gunned down had the squabble not resulted in him being forced to ride with Vice President Lyndon B. Johnson (1908-1973). The past comes to life through the author’s masterful storytelling in which the main characters assume their positions in a tragedy we know is unfolding.

Because the book is a re-creation of the past, there does exist the possibility that certain dialogue may have been added and/or changed. Manchester did conduct extensive research for the book, and it is my belief that the book is correct. However, it should be noted that Jackie did not approve of the first manuscript and asked Manchester to amend it. The completed manuscript that resulted in this book is admirable, but I did notice things that struck me as odd. The murder of Dallas Police Officer J.D. Tippit (1924-1963) receives little attention in the story and is mentioned in passing. I also found statements from the author regarding Oswald’s alleged guilt to be slightly misleading. Assassination researchers will notice these things instantly. In Manchester’s defense, the book was not intended to be a critique of the crime or the Warren Commission. His assignment was to cover the Kennedy group from start to finish and in that regard he succeeded. But to be fair to the historical record, I belief assertions that Oswald was guilty are open to debate as there are still things about his life that remain a mystery.

After chaos breaks out in Dealey Plaza, the scene shifts to Parkland Hospital. Again, Manchester captures the atmosphere perfectly and supplies a thorough discussion of the panic that ensued following the shooting. Despite first reports, those closest to Kennedy knew the head wound was fatal. However, doctors did what they could before pronouncing him dead. Following the official declaration of death, the book produces a somber feeling as the group must take the body home and prepare for a funeral. The new Commander-In-Chief, Lyndon Johnson, comes across quite differently to what he has been portrayed as elsewhere. Grief consumed the presidential party and as we see in the book, each person managed it differently. This is another area where the book excels. The names of aides and officials will be familiar to readers but here they are parts of the story that do not produce an uplifting conclusion. I can only imagine the thoughts they had as the realization that Kennedy had just been murdered settled in. After making a rough departure from Parkland Hospital and Love Field, Air Force One is soon airborne and on its way back to the nation’s capital. But the story is far from over.

After arriving in Maryland, an autopsy is ordered, and Manchester re-tells the story of the arrival from Dallas. He does not discuss forensic aspects of the autopsy in detail but keeps the focus on the new widowed Jackie and the task of burying Kennedy. At this part of the story, Attorney General Robert F. Kennedy (1925-1968) becomes more of a presence as he aides his sister-in-law with the challenging task of saying goodbye to Jack. Readers interested in the funeral preparations and decisions that produced what was seen on television will appreciate this section. There is no joy to be found but what can be appreciated are the painstaking decisions and tasks executed by those who loved the late president. The impact of Kennedy’s death cannot be understated, and Manchester again captures the public sentiment and worldwide sadness in the wake of the assassination. The book’s inevitable conclusion slowly approaches as the funeral procession marches towards Arlington National Cemetery. The events seen on television screens are explained as a backdrop before Manchester closes the discussion.

Although I did find misstatements in the book, I still enjoyed reading it. Manchester brilliantly chronicled the Texas trip and the devastating fallout. Conspiracy theorists and researchers will know the story inside and out but for others who are not familiar with the Kennedy murder, this book is a reliable source of information about the reasons for the trip, the mood behind-the-scenes and the extraordinary effort needed to bring Kennedy home and restore order to Washington. There are things about the assassination we may never learn but Manchester’s work is a crucial part in keeping the historical record intact.

ISBN-10:‎ 0316370711
ISBN-13:‎ 978-0316370714